Clash or Pistols: Who was more righteous with their music?


Written by:

The Sex Pistols may have been the first British punk rock band, but The Clash were the real definitive British punk rockers. Brash, fiery and bolstered with an outlaw image, they were charged with a certain righteousness that only a select few punks were able to pull off.

Despite a band that seemingly had “traditional” roots in upbringing, they were a band who evidently restored the pre-emptive passion and protest of rock ‘n’ roll, charting a course of explosive chaos that lasted all but 10 years.

Although a comparatively short time to what they set out for, they amassed a devout following on both sides of the Atlantic. From initial intrigue with 1977’s The Clash to mass pandemonium with London Calling in 1979 and finally settling on an established legendary status finalising on Combat Rock a mere three years later, the band were more of a spark of excitement and rebellion, and less of a fizzle-out of relevancy where you see now 40 years later down the line.

Although the discussions regarding Pistols v Clash will go on for many years, I don’t think it’s more of a straight victory as opposed to a two-horse race between the two punk giants.

While Sex Pistols were devoid of accepting any sense of moral principles – literal anarchy in the UK – , The Clash were a more emotionally-charged band, filtered with an understanding of supporting leftist political ideologies. Often, this careened into an adventure exploring musical lanes of roots of reggae and blues, all the while staying true to the mechanics of hard rock. Just take a look at Train in Vain (Stand By Me)!

What must be understood the most however, is how integral it is to keep this magic of punk rock centred in the forefront of our minds, aware of where we came from and where we are now. There it still a presence of punk-rock idolisation among the current bands we see today – Idles and Shame to name a few – but it’s worth mentioning that it certainly hasn’t been the same since the 1970s, and especially since Thatcher’s London, might I add. It will only take the same Tory Government to get all those rebellious punks crawling out of the woodwork again..


4 responses to “Clash or Pistols: Who was more righteous with their music?”

  1. Tales from the Neon Beach avatar
    Tales from the Neon Beach

    I just see The Sex Pistols as a single entity. I don’t mind the odd Clash song but I have never listened to any of their albums.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. manvmusic avatar

      You reckon so? You reckon they stand out all the way on their own> you’re right thinking that way, to be fair. You could argue that they single-handedly brought a new movement of punk to wrought and writher about.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Tales from the Neon Beach avatar
    Tales from the Neon Beach

    It’s about the music, the fashion and a melting point of individuals with something unique to say. Pure chaos and it’s hard to capture that.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. manvmusic avatar

      Yeah, it certainly is.. they gave it a good go though! Notably two of the most important acts we’ve come through for our music movements. Any new ones you’re listening to at the moment?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Latest Stories

%d bloggers like this: